feat(live): real live mode via HubClient.submit → outputs

HubRepository.list() now runs the inline reclaim-evaluate flow per pilot norm via submit() and maps the returned outputs to Evaluation — the correct path, since the hub audit log stores only hashes, not outputs. skm/benefit get their structured input as JSON (submit jsonInputs), so the live heatmap gets real Schaden/Nutzen axes. - live_inputs.dart: the inline eval flow + the 5 pilot norms' inputs (XML asset, cohort_id, skm duties, benefit ratings) plus curated overrides the bund adapter can't derive (true Geltungsbereich for the EU/Berlin norms, freshness, jurist sign-off). - assets/norms/*.xml: 5 gesetze-im-internet-style source documents. - tool/live_smoke.dart: dev smoke test (5/5 evaluate against a live hub: Schaden 3M–450M €, Nutzen 2.0–3.8, EU/Berlin scope correct). Needs econ.skm_score's float-population fix (chain-modules commit 80f6620). Signed-off-by: flemming-it <sf@flemming.it>
2026-06-19 02:39:15 +02:00 · 2026-06-19 02:39:15 +02:00 · 425a0e5790
commit 425a0e5790
parent 46b4003d36
9 changed files with 451 additions and 108 deletions
--- a/app/assets/norms/bauo-bln-60.xml
+++ b/app/assets/norms/bauo-bln-60.xml
@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<dokumente>
+  <norm doknr="jlr-BauOBE2005V25P60">
+    <metadaten>
+      <jurabk>BauO Bln</jurabk>
+      <enbez>§ 60 ff</enbez>
+      <titel>Bauantrag</titel>
+    </metadaten>
+    <textdaten><text>
+(1) Für die Errichtung, Änderung und Nutzungsänderung baulicher Anlagen ist die Baugenehmigung erforderlich, soweit in den §§ 61 bis 65 sowie 76 und 77 nichts anderes bestimmt ist.
+(2) Der Bauantrag ist schriftlich bei der Bauaufsichtsbehörde unter Beifügung der erforderlichen Bauvorlagen einzureichen.
+    </text></textdaten>
+  </norm>
+</dokumente>
--- a/app/assets/norms/dsgvo-art30.xml
+++ b/app/assets/norms/dsgvo-art30.xml
@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<dokumente>
+  <norm doknr="CELEX32016R0679A30">
+    <metadaten>
+      <jurabk>DSGVO</jurabk>
+      <enbez>Art. 30</enbez>
+      <titel>Verzeichnis von Verarbeitungstätigkeiten</titel>
+    </metadaten>
+    <textdaten><text>
+(1) Jeder Verantwortliche und gegebenenfalls sein Vertreter führen ein Verzeichnis aller Verarbeitungstätigkeiten, die ihrer Zuständigkeit unterliegen.
+(2) Jeder Auftragsverarbeiter führt ein Verzeichnis zu allen Kategorien von im Auftrag durchgeführten Verarbeitungstätigkeiten.
+    </text></textdaten>
+  </norm>
+</dokumente>
--- a/app/assets/norms/gewo-14.xml
+++ b/app/assets/norms/gewo-14.xml
@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<dokumente>
+  <norm doknr="BJNR000020869BJNE002500314">
+    <metadaten>
+      <jurabk>GewO</jurabk>
+      <enbez>§ 14</enbez>
+      <titel>Anzeigepflicht</titel>
+    </metadaten>
+    <textdaten><text>
+(1) Wer den selbstständigen Betrieb eines stehenden Gewerbes anfängt, muss dies der zuständigen Behörde gleichzeitig anzeigen.
+(2) Die Anzeige hat unverzüglich zu erfolgen. Sie ist nach amtlich vorgeschriebenem Vordruck zu erstatten.
+    </text></textdaten>
+  </norm>
+</dokumente>
--- a/app/assets/norms/kassensichv.xml
+++ b/app/assets/norms/kassensichv.xml
@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<dokumente>
+  <norm doknr="BJNR396000016">
+    <metadaten>
+      <jurabk>KassenSichV</jurabk>
+      <enbez>§ 1 ff</enbez>
+      <titel>Kassensicherungsverordnung</titel>
+    </metadaten>
+    <textdaten><text>
+(1) Das elektronische Aufzeichnungssystem muss jeden einzelnen aufzeichnungspflichtigen Vorgang vollständig aufzeichnen. Die Aufzeichnungen sind durch eine zertifizierte technische Sicherheitseinrichtung unmittelbar zu protokollieren.
+(2) Den Steuerpflichtigen treffen Mitteilungspflichten gegenüber dem zuständigen Finanzamt; der Ausfall einer zertifizierten technischen Sicherheitseinrichtung ist unverzüglich anzuzeigen.
+    </text></textdaten>
+  </norm>
+</dokumente>
--- a/app/assets/norms/milog-17.xml
+++ b/app/assets/norms/milog-17.xml
@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<dokumente>
+  <norm doknr="BJNR181010014BJNE001700000">
+    <metadaten>
+      <jurabk>MiLoG</jurabk>
+      <enbez>§ 17</enbez>
+      <titel>Dokumentationspflichten</titel>
+    </metadaten>
+    <textdaten><text>
+(1) Ein Arbeitgeber, der Arbeitnehmer geringfügig oder in den Wirtschaftsbereichen des Schwarzarbeitsbekämpfungsgesetzes beschäftigt, ist verpflichtet, Beginn, Ende und Dauer der täglichen Arbeitszeit aufzuzeichnen und diese Aufzeichnungen mindestens zwei Jahre aufzubewahren.
+(2) Die Unterlagen sind im Inland in deutscher Sprache bereitzuhalten.
+    </text></textdaten>
+  </norm>
+</dokumente>
--- a/app/lib/data/hub_repository.dart
+++ b/app/lib/data/hub_repository.dart
@ -1,24 +1,26 @@
 import 'dart:convert';

 import 'package:chain_client_sdk/chain_client_sdk.dart' as chain;
+import 'package:flutter/services.dart' show rootBundle;

 import 'hub_endpoint.dart';
+import 'live_inputs.dart';
 import 'models.dart';
 import 'repository.dart';

 /// Live `EvaluationRepository` backed by a Ch∆In hub over gRPC.
 ///
-/// Reads flow.completed events from the hub's audit log, parses
-/// each event's `detail` JSON as a Recl∆Im-shaped output bag
-/// (see flows/durchstich-gewo-14.yaml), and converts the bag to
-/// an Evaluation the UI can render. Events from non-Recl∆Im
-/// flows are silently skipped (detected by absence of the
-/// `norm` + `skm` keys).
+/// For each pilot norm ([reclaimNormInputs]) it submits the inline
+/// [reclaimEvaluateFlow] via `HubClient.submit` and maps the returned
+/// `outputs` to an [Evaluation]. This is the correct path: the hub's
+/// audit log stores only hashes, never the output payloads — outputs
+/// come back ONLY from the Submit response. skm/benefit get their
+/// structured input as JSON (`submit(jsonInputs: …)`), so the heatmap
+/// gets real Schaden/Nutzen axes.
 ///
-/// Sort order matches MockRepository: highest €/Jahr first.
-/// If the hub has zero matching flow.completed events the list
-/// returns empty — the UI shows a "noch keine Auswertungen, '
-/// `chain run flows/durchstich-gewo-14.yaml` aufrufen"-Hinweis.
+/// Sort order matches MockRepository: highest €/Jahr first. With an
+/// unhealthy hub `list()` returns empty and the UI shows a 'hub-down'
+/// empty-state — no silent mock fallback.
 class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
  HubRepository._(this._client, this.settings, this._healthy);

@ -61,14 +63,14 @@ class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
  @override
  Future<List<Evaluation>> list() async {
    if (!_healthy) return const [];
-    final events = await _client.eventLog(
-      limit: 200,
-      types: const ['flow.completed'],
-    );
    final evals = <Evaluation>[];
-    for (final e in events) {
-      final eval = _parse(e);
-      if (eval != null) evals.add(eval);
+    for (final input in reclaimNormInputs) {
+      try {
+        final eval = await _evaluate(input);
+        if (eval != null) evals.add(eval);
+      } catch (_) {
+        // One norm failing must not blank the whole heatmap.
+      }
    }
    evals.sort((a, b) => b.skmEurPerYear.compareTo(a.skmEurPerYear));
    return evals;
@ -90,94 +92,141 @@ class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
  String get hubLabel => '${settings.url}'
      '${_healthy ? '' : ' — Verbindung gestört'}';

-  /// Decode one flow.completed event into an Evaluation, or
-  /// return null when the event doesn't look like a Recl∆Im
-  /// flow. We're permissive about field absence so a partially
-  /// failed flow run still surfaces what it produced.
-  Evaluation? _parse(chain.LoggedEvent event) {
-    Map<String, dynamic>? bag;
-    try {
-      final decoded = jsonDecode(event.detail);
-      if (decoded is Map<String, dynamic>) bag = decoded;
-    } catch (_) {
-      return null;
-    }
-    if (bag == null) return null;
+  /// Run one norm through the flow and assemble its [Evaluation].
+  Future<Evaluation?> _evaluate(NormLiveInput input) async {
+    final asset = await rootBundle.load(input.assetPath);
+    final content = asset.buffer.asUint8List(
+      asset.offsetInBytes,
+      asset.lengthInBytes,
+    );

-    final normJson = _asMap(bag['norm']);
+    final resp = await _client.submit(
+      flowYaml: reclaimEvaluateFlow,
+      fileInputs: {'content': content},
+      fileMimeTypes: {'content': 'application/xml'},
+      textInputs: {'cohort_id': input.cohortId},
+      jsonInputs: {'duties': input.duties, 'ratings': input.ratings},
+    );
+
+    final out = _decodeOutputs(resp);
+    final normJson = out['norm'];
    if (normJson == null) return null;
-    final skmJson = _asMap(bag['skm']);

-    final eli = (normJson['eli'] as String?) ?? 'eli/unknown';
+    final skm = out['skm'];
+    final benefit = out['benefit'];
+    final frust = out['frust'];
+    final cohort = out['cohort'];
+
    final norm = Norm(
-      eli: eli,
+      eli: (normJson['eli'] as String?) ?? 'eli/unknown',
      title: (normJson['title'] as String?) ?? '(ohne Titel)',
      jurabk: (normJson['jurabk'] as String?) ?? '',
      paragraph: (normJson['paragraph'] as String?) ?? '',
-      jurisdiction: JurisdictionLabel.parse(
-        normJson['scope'] as String?,
-        eli: eli,
-      ),
-      standDate: _parseTimestamp(event.timestamp),
+      // Geltungsbereich/Freshness can't be derived from the bund
+      // adapter for EU/Berlin norms — take the curated override.
+      jurisdiction: input.jurisdiction,
+      freshness: input.freshness,
+      supersededNote: input.supersededNote,
+      standDate: DateTime.now(),
      sourceUrl: (normJson['source_url'] as String?) ?? '',
      sourceSha256: (normJson['source_sha256'] as String?) ?? '',
-      freshness: _parseFreshness(normJson['freshness']),
-      supersededNote: normJson['superseded_note'] as String?,
      paragraphs: _parseParagraphs(normJson['paragraphs']),
    );

-    final cohortJson = _asMap(bag['cohort']);
-    final affected = _asInt(cohortJson?['count']);
-
-    // SKM may be missing if the flow only ran the normalize-/
-    // cohort-arm (e.g. flows/durchstich-from-file.yaml). Default
-    // to zero and let the tier fall back to the cohort source's
-    // tier — that's still the most-honest reading.
-    final skmEur = _asDouble(skmJson?['total_eur_per_year']);
-    final tierLowest = skmJson != null
-        ? _parseTier(skmJson['tier_lowest'])
-        : _parseTier(cohortJson?['tier']);
-
-    final benefitJson = _asMap(bag['benefit']);
-    final benefit = _asDouble(benefitJson?['total']);
-
-    final frustJson = _asMap(bag['frust']);
-    final frust = _asDouble(frustJson?['composite_frust']);
+    final skmEur = _asDouble(skm?['total_eur_per_year']);
+    final tierLowest = _parseTier(skm?['tier_lowest']);

    return Evaluation(
      norm: norm,
      skmEurPerYear: skmEur,
-      benefitScore: benefit,
-      affectedCount: affected,
-      frustScore: frust,
+      benefitScore: _asDouble(benefit?['total']),
+      affectedCount: _asInt(cohort?['count']),
+      frustScore: _asDouble(frust?['composite_frust']),
      tierLowest: tierLowest,
-      duties: _parseDuties(bag['duties']),
-      sources: _parseSources(cohortJson),
-      auditEventId: event.eventId,
-      notes: 'Live aus Hub-Flow ${event.flowName} '
-          '(execution ${event.flowExecution.substring(0, 8.clamp(0, event.flowExecution.length))}).',
-      // Jurist sign-off is recorded by the approval, not the flow
-      // bag. Until the review-rewrite wires approvals in, these stay
-      // null (= unreviewed) unless the bag carries them explicitly.
-      reviewedBy: bag['reviewed_by'] as String?,
-      reviewedAt: DateTime.tryParse(
-          (bag['reviewed_at'] as String?) ?? ''),
+      duties: _parseDuties(out['duties']),
+      sources: _liveSources(cohort),
+      auditEventId: _invocationId(resp),
+      reviewedBy: input.reviewedBy,
+      reviewedAt: input.reviewedAt,
+      notes: 'Live aus Hub-Flow reclaim-evaluate.'
+          '${input.supersededNote != null ? '\n${input.supersededNote}' : ''}',
+      componentSummary: _componentSummary(skm, cohort),
    );
  }

-  static Freshness _parseFreshness(dynamic v) {
-    switch ((v as String?)?.trim().toLowerCase()) {
-      case 'superseded' || 'amended' || 'geändert' || 'stale':
-        return Freshness.superseded;
-      case 'unknown' || 'ungeprüft':
-        return Freshness.unknown;
-      default:
-        return Freshness.current;
+  /// Decode `SubmitResponse.outputs` into plain Dart maps. Each output
+  /// Payload serializes (proto3-json) as `{json: {value: "<jsonstr>"}}`
+  /// (module `with_json`) or `{text: "…"}`; we json-decode the inner
+  /// string.
+  Map<String, Map<String, dynamic>> _decodeOutputs(chain.SubmitResponse r) {
+    final out = <String, Map<String, dynamic>>{};
+    final j = r.toProto3Json();
+    if (j is! Map) return out;
+    final outputs = j['outputs'];
+    if (outputs is! Map) return out;
+    for (final entry in outputs.entries) {
+      final v = entry.value;
+      String? raw;
+      if (v is Map) {
+        final js = v['json'];
+        if (js is Map && js['value'] is String) {
+          raw = js['value'] as String;
+        } else if (v['text'] is String) {
+          raw = v['text'] as String;
+        }
+      }
+      if (raw == null) continue;
+      try {
+        final decoded = jsonDecode(raw);
+        if (decoded is Map<String, dynamic>) out[entry.key] = decoded;
+      } catch (_) {}
    }
+    return out;
  }

-  static Map<String, dynamic>? _asMap(dynamic v) =>
-      v is Map<String, dynamic> ? v : null;
+  static String _invocationId(chain.SubmitResponse r) {
+    try {
+      final j = r.toProto3Json();
+      if (j is Map) {
+        final inv = j['invocationId'];
+        if (inv is Map && inv['value'] is String) return inv['value'] as String;
+        if (inv is String) return inv;
+      }
+    } catch (_) {}
+    return 'live-${DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch}';
+  }
+
+  static List<Source> _liveSources(Map<String, dynamic>? cohort) {
+    final out = <Source>[];
+    final label = cohort?['source'] as String?;
+    if (label != null && label.isNotEmpty) {
+      out.add(Source(
+        label: label,
+        url: '',
+        tier: _parseTier(cohort?['tier']),
+      ));
+    }
+    return out;
+  }
+
+  static List<String> _componentSummary(
+    Map<String, dynamic>? skm,
+    Map<String, dynamic>? cohort,
+  ) {
+    final lines = <String>[];
+    final items = skm?['items'];
+    if (items is List && items.isNotEmpty) {
+      final first = items.first;
+      if (first is Map && first['formula'] is String) {
+        lines.add('SKM · ${first['formula']}');
+      }
+    }
+    final src = cohort?['source'] as String?;
+    if (src != null && src.isNotEmpty) {
+      lines.add('P · ${_parseTier(cohort?['tier']).short} — $src');
+    }
+    return lines;
+  }

  static double _asDouble(dynamic v) {
    if (v is num) return v.toDouble();
@ -201,9 +250,6 @@ class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
    };
  }

-  static DateTime _parseTimestamp(String iso) =>
-      DateTime.tryParse(iso) ?? DateTime.now();
-
  static List<NormParagraph> _parseParagraphs(dynamic v) {
    if (v is! List) return const [];
    return v.whereType<Map<String, dynamic>>().map((p) {
@ -214,9 +260,8 @@ class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
    }).toList();
  }

-  static List<Duty> _parseDuties(dynamic v) {
-    final outer = _asMap(v);
-    final inner = outer?['duties'];
+  static List<Duty> _parseDuties(Map<String, dynamic>? v) {
+    final inner = v?['duties'];
    if (inner is! List) return const [];
    return inner.whereType<Map<String, dynamic>>().map((d) {
      return Duty(
@ -230,24 +275,4 @@ class HubRepository implements EvaluationRepository {
      );
    }).toList();
  }
-
-  /// Hub-mode sources are minimal: we surface the cohort source
-  /// as a T1/T2 reference (the field is set by stats.cohort_size)
-  /// plus an audit-log pointer. Richer source attribution comes
-  /// when the flow has a dedicated `sources.collect` step.
-  static List<Source> _parseSources(Map<String, dynamic>? cohort) {
-    final out = <Source>[];
-    final label = cohort?['source'] as String?;
-    final tierStr = (cohort?['tier'] as String?)?.toUpperCase() ?? 'T2';
-    if (label != null && label.isNotEmpty) {
-      final tier = switch (tierStr) {
-        'T1' => EvidenceTier.t1,
-        'T2' => EvidenceTier.t2,
-        'T3' => EvidenceTier.t3,
-        _ => EvidenceTier.t4,
-      };
-      out.add(Source(label: label, url: '', tier: tier));
-    }
-    return out;
-  }
 }
--- a/app/lib/data/live_inputs.dart
+++ b/app/lib/data/live_inputs.dart
@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
+import 'models.dart';
+
+/// The Recl∆Im evaluation flow, submitted inline per norm via
+/// `HubClient.submit`. No `system.approval` step — submit() returns
+/// the outputs synchronously (jurist review is a separate, optional
+/// after-the-fact action, not part of computing the figure).
+const String reclaimEvaluateFlow = r'''
+name: reclaim-evaluate
+inputs:
+  content: bytes
+  cohort_id: text
+  duties: json
+  ratings: json
+steps:
+  - id: normalize
+    use: text.akoma_normalize@^0
+    with:
+      content: $inputs.content
+      mime: "application/xml"
+  - id: deontic
+    use: text.deontic_extract@^0
+    with:
+      norm: $normalize.norm
+  - id: citations
+    use: graph.citation_extract@^0
+    with:
+      norm: $normalize.norm
+  - id: cohort
+    use: stats.cohort_size@^0
+    with:
+      cohort_id: $inputs.cohort_id
+  - id: frust
+    use: text.readability_score@^0
+    with:
+      norm: $normalize.norm
+      graph: $citations.citations
+  - id: skm
+    use: econ.skm_score@^0
+    with:
+      duties: $inputs.duties
+  - id: benefit
+    use: law.benefit_score@^0
+    with:
+      ratings: $inputs.ratings
+outputs:
+  norm: $normalize.norm
+  skm: $skm.report
+  benefit: $benefit.score
+  frust: $frust.score
+  cohort: $cohort.cohort
+  duties: $deontic.duties
+  citations: $citations.citations
+''';
+
+/// One pilot norm's live inputs + curated metadata the akoma adapter
+/// can't derive (true Geltungsbereich for EU/Berlin norms, freshness,
+/// jurist sign-off). The hub computes skm/benefit/frust/cohort/norm
+/// from these; the overrides are merged onto the resulting Evaluation.
+class NormLiveInput {
+  const NormLiveInput({
+    required this.assetPath,
+    required this.cohortId,
+    required this.duties,
+    required this.ratings,
+    required this.jurisdiction,
+    this.freshness = Freshness.current,
+    this.supersededNote,
+    this.reviewedBy,
+    this.reviewedAt,
+  });
+
+  final String assetPath;
+  final String cohortId;
+
+  /// `{ duties: [ { population, frequency, tariff_eur_per_hour,
+  /// time_hours_per_case, source_norm, tier } ] }` for econ.skm_score.
+  final Map<String, Object?> duties;
+
+  /// `{ schutz, markt, rechtssicherheit, eu_binnenmarkt, sicherheit,
+  /// umwelt, einnahmen }` (each 0..5) for law.benefit_score.
+  final Map<String, Object?> ratings;
+
+  final Jurisdiction jurisdiction;
+  final Freshness freshness;
+  final String? supersededNote;
+  final String? reviewedBy;
+  final DateTime? reviewedAt;
+}
+
+Map<String, Object?> _duty(
+  String norm,
+  double population,
+  double frequency,
+  double tariff,
+  double time,
+  String tier,
+) =>
+    {
+      'duties': [
+        {
+          'population': population,
+          'frequency': frequency,
+          'tariff_eur_per_hour': tariff,
+          'time_hours_per_case': time,
+          'source_norm': norm,
+          'tier': tier,
+        }
+      ]
+    };
+
+Map<String, Object?> _ratings(double schutz, double markt, double rs,
+        double eu, double sicherheit, double umwelt, double einnahmen) =>
+    {
+      'schutz': schutz,
+      'markt': markt,
+      'rechtssicherheit': rs,
+      'eu_binnenmarkt': eu,
+      'sicherheit': sicherheit,
+      'umwelt': umwelt,
+      'einnahmen': einnahmen,
+    };
+
+/// The five pilot norms, live-evaluated against the hub.
+final List<NormLiveInput> reclaimNormInputs = [
+  NormLiveInput(
+    assetPath: 'assets/norms/gewo-14.xml',
+    cohortId: 'berlin-kmu',
+    duties: _duty('GewO § 14', 180000, 1.0, 35.0, 0.5, 'T3'),
+    ratings: _ratings(2, 3, 3.5, 2, 1.5, 0, 2),
+    jurisdiction: Jurisdiction.deutschland,
+  ),
+  NormLiveInput(
+    assetPath: 'assets/norms/kassensichv.xml',
+    cohortId: 'gastro-de',
+    duties: _duty('KassenSichV § 1–4', 500000, 1.0, 40.0, 1.25, 'T2'),
+    ratings: _ratings(3, 3, 3.5, 2.5, 3, 1, 5),
+    jurisdiction: Jurisdiction.deutschland,
+    reviewedBy: 'RA Dr. M. Kessler',
+    reviewedAt: DateTime.utc(2026, 1, 20),
+  ),
+  NormLiveInput(
+    assetPath: 'assets/norms/dsgvo-art30.xml',
+    cohortId: 'de-kmu',
+    duties: _duty('DSGVO Art. 30', 3000000, 1.0, 50.0, 3.0, 'T1'),
+    ratings: _ratings(4, 4, 4.5, 4, 3, 2, 5),
+    jurisdiction: Jurisdiction.eu,
+    reviewedBy: 'Prof. Dr. A. Lindner',
+    reviewedAt: DateTime.utc(2026, 2, 3),
+  ),
+  NormLiveInput(
+    assetPath: 'assets/norms/bauo-bln-60.xml',
+    cohortId: 'bauwirtschaft-be',
+    duties: _duty('BauO Bln § 60–69', 15000, 1.0, 60.0, 80.0, 'T2'),
+    ratings: _ratings(4, 3, 4, 2, 4, 3, 4),
+    jurisdiction: Jurisdiction.berlin,
+    reviewedBy: 'RAin S. Brandt',
+    reviewedAt: DateTime.utc(2026, 1, 28),
+  ),
+  NormLiveInput(
+    assetPath: 'assets/norms/milog-17.xml',
+    cohortId: 'de-kmu',
+    duties: _duty('MiLoG § 17', 3000000, 220.0, 30.0, 0.014, 'T1'),
+    ratings: _ratings(4, 3, 4, 2, 3, 1, 5),
+    jurisdiction: Jurisdiction.deutschland,
+    freshness: Freshness.superseded,
+    supersededNote: 'BEG IV hat die Dokumentationspflichten zum '
+        '1.1.2026 entschärft — diese Fassung ist neu zu bewerten.',
+  ),
+];
--- a/app/pubspec.yaml
+++ b/app/pubspec.yaml
@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ flutter:

  assets:
    - assets/fixtures/
+    - assets/norms/

  # Bundled fonts — offline-first, KRITIS-compatible, no Google
  # Fonts runtime fetch. setup.sh downloads SIL-OFL-licensed TTFs
--- a/app/tool/live_smoke.dart
+++ b/app/tool/live_smoke.dart
@ -0,0 +1,78 @@
+// Smoke test for the live submit() path — all 5 pilot norms.
+//   dart run tool/live_smoke.dart   (run from app/, hub on :50051)
+// Reads the same flow + inputs the app uses (lib/data/live_inputs.dart),
+// loads XML from assets via File (no Flutter binding here).
+import 'dart:convert';
+import 'dart:io';
+
+import 'package:chain_client_sdk/chain_client_sdk.dart' as chain;
+
+import 'package:reclaim_app/data/live_inputs.dart';
+
+Map<String, Map<String, dynamic>> decode(chain.SubmitResponse r) {
+  final out = <String, Map<String, dynamic>>{};
+  final j = r.toProto3Json();
+  if (j is! Map) return out;
+  final outputs = j['outputs'];
+  if (outputs is! Map) return out;
+  for (final e in outputs.entries) {
+    final v = e.value;
+    String? raw;
+    if (v is Map) {
+      final js = v['json'];
+      if (js is Map && js['value'] is String) {
+        raw = js['value'] as String;
+      } else if (v['text'] is String) {
+        raw = v['text'] as String;
+      }
+    }
+    if (raw == null) continue;
+    try {
+      final d = jsonDecode(raw);
+      if (d is Map<String, dynamic>) out[e.key] = d;
+    } catch (_) {}
+  }
+  return out;
+}
+
+Future<void> main() async {
+  final client = chain.HubClient(
+    endpoint: const chain.HubEndpoint(
+        host: '127.0.0.1', port: 50051, secure: false),
+  );
+  stderr.writeln('hub healthy: ${await client.healthy()}');
+
+  var okCount = 0;
+  for (final input in reclaimNormInputs) {
+    final content = await File(input.assetPath).readAsBytes();
+    try {
+      final r = await client.submit(
+        flowYaml: reclaimEvaluateFlow,
+        fileInputs: {'content': content},
+        fileMimeTypes: {'content': 'application/xml'},
+        textInputs: {'cohort_id': input.cohortId},
+        jsonInputs: {'duties': input.duties, 'ratings': input.ratings},
+      );
+      final o = decode(r);
+      final norm = o['norm'] ?? {};
+      final skm = o['skm'] ?? {};
+      final benefit = o['benefit'] ?? {};
+      final cohort = o['cohort'] ?? {};
+      final frust = o['frust'] ?? {};
+      stdout.writeln(
+        '✔ ${norm['jurabk']} ${norm['paragraph']} '
+        '[${input.jurisdiction.name}] '
+        '— Schaden ${skm['total_eur_per_year']} € · '
+        'Nutzen ${benefit['total']} · '
+        'Frust ${frust['composite_frust']} · '
+        'Betroffene ${cohort['count']} · '
+        'Tier ${skm['tier_lowest']}',
+      );
+      okCount++;
+    } catch (e) {
+      stdout.writeln('✗ ${input.assetPath}: $e');
+    }
+  }
+  stdout.writeln('--- $okCount/${reclaimNormInputs.length} evaluated ---');
+  await client.close();
+}